Sunday, June 29, 2014

Week 1 Two Cultures

I am a fourth year cultural anthropology student, this is actually my last class that I am taking in order to graduate as I am just 5 units short of the minimum 180 units necessary for graduation. I find it interesting that there is still an active debate surrounding the separation of cultures between the intellectual and the scientific with potential for the artist to bridge the gap. I am not surprised by the distinction between the two cultures because I am a product of a society that is founded on these principles. I have been brought up to believe that the disparity between these two fields of academic expertise is significant enough to warrant their separation but I cannot help but to think that this particular paradigm is outdated. Even on the UCLA campus the division between educational clusters is clear. There are further divisions within the scientific field between the traditional hard sciences and the more contemporary sciences like the humanities, life sciences, and social sciences. All of my anthropology classes for instance took place on North campus while the natural sciences were conducted on South campus. I think that old stereotypes are mostly to blame for this type of model that leaves little room for the blending of ideas between disciplines, as well as a school structure that resembles that of an assembly line. I am curious why this form of learning has persisted for so long after being the subject of critique for so many years. I am hopeful that one day the currently held notions of what it means to be educated will be challenged to the point that a blending of cultures will result, not just a bridging of the gap between them. The next generation of scientists and intellectuals should have a firm understanding of the foundations in which their counterpart’s ideas originated and artists should be able to draw their inspiration from both disciplines as they see fit in order to better express themselves artistically and ultimately help to shift preexisting cultural paradigms.

The following picture is a visual representation of a common misconception that there is a distinction between the left and right hemispheres of the brain and that it determines your ability or inability to perform certain tasks well. Although there is some merit to this idea, you are not biologically determined to fail or succeed at a task because you are left or right brained so to speak.

Here Richard Dawkins a world renown evolutionary biologist explains why science is art.

This is the goal for science and art to meet and produce the next generation of ideas.
Sources
Two Cultures Lectures
Toward a Third Culture: Being in between

Victoria Vesna
Leonardo, Vol. 34, No. 2. (2001), pp. 121-125.
Stable URL:
http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0024-094X%282001%2934%3A2%3C121%3ATATCBI%3E2.0.CO%3B2-3

3 comments:

  1. Cultural anthropology will be an interesting perspective to come to this course from. In many ways the history of anthropology in deeply bound up in the colonial powers and institutional formations that have lead to the disciplinary divisions that the "two cultures" argument builds off of.



    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I strongly disagree with your statement that it is a misconception that there is a distinction between the left and right hemispheres of the brain which determines our ability or inability to perform certain tasks. I don't believe we are not biologically determined to fail or succeed at tasks because we are right or left brained. Based on my life experience, I suffered a brain injury, a bleed in the right hemisphere of my brain as a child which severely diminished strength and sensation on the left side of my body because it was in my brain's right hemisphere. My ability to perform certain fine motor tasks like drawing figures and tracking lines were affected, while many cognitive, processing and computational skills were not. This was explained by neurologists and neurosurgeons and borne out with tests by neuropsychologists and worked on with speech, physical and occupational therapists. This is not a matter of conceptions or misconceptions, it's a matter of science and fact.

    ReplyDelete